Online ordering powered by Seamless
731 9TH AVENUE (9th Ave. Between 49th St. & 50th St.)(212) 245-2360
Minimum order of $15.00 is required for delivery
Delivery estimate is 25-40 min (more info)
Unfortunately, Amish Market West is not open at the delivery/pickup time that you selected. Please make sure that you've entered an address and try changing the time in the Order Information section to the right.
Seamless allows you to enjoy convenient online ordering from the best local restaurants. If you're ordering for the first time, start your order by entering your address to the right. Return users log in here.
Delivery estimate is 30 - 45 min (more info)
Print this menu
Made fresh daily.
8 pieces.
8 rolls.
Inside-out rolls. 12 pieces.
No trans fat, no gluten, no partially hydrogenated oil, no high fructose corn syrup, lactose free.
With standards for supermarkets rising and customers no longer willing to accept anything but the freshest products, Amish Market has taken these issues to heart. Generic merchandise served in a drab atmosphere is no longer good enough for people who have a genuine diversity of options for buying their groceries. This is why New York’s fine food lovers have made Amish Market one of the most popular grocery stores in the city.
There is no horse and buggy here, but many of the products still do come straight from Amish sellers in Lancaster, Pa. But that’s not all, because Amish Market is committed to being a one-stop shop for any and all of your food needs. And that includes special niches such as wheat- or gluten-free food, as well as a variety of deli-style sandwiches, salads, pizzas and more for lunch and dinner. So next time you think of ordering food, think of ordering from Amish Market.
Honey Turkey Sandwich—With brie, peppers, green apple and lettuce
Amish Grilled Chicken Wrap—Grilled chicken, avocado, green leaf lettuce, roasted peppers, onions and special sauce
New York Combo Panini—Pastrami, corned beef, provolone cheese, lettuce, tomato, mustard and house dressing
Quattro Formaggi Pizza—With Pecorino Romano, parmesan, provolone and fresh mozzarella
Rigatoni Bolognese—With homemade meat sauce
Lamb Shish Kebab Plate—Served with two sides
Not in our delivery zone? Please visit our other Amish Market locations around Manhattan:
Amish Market East
240 East 45th St.
(212) 370-1761
Amish Market Tribeca
53 PARK PLACE
(212) 608-3863
Amish Market is also available to cater your next party or corporate event. Please click here to view our catering menu and place an order online.
I have been ordering from them almost every day lately. The grasshopper juice tastes fresh and amazing and soups are hearty. They always hit the delivery window and the delivery person is friendly. Strongly recommended!
Posted a month ago by Jia Z.
good taste, ok amount of chicken, would order again
Posted 2 months ago by Fred W.
What happened to the pizza oven?! Would have given more stars but lack of pizza = lack of stars.
Posted 3 months ago by Jennifer L.
Bring back the pizza oven!!!!!
Posted 3 months ago by Kandice T.
I used to order from Amish Market all the time. Then, all of a sudden, their entire hot oven sandwiches menu disappeared. I will no longer be ordering from them.
Posted 3 months ago by Jesse K.
Horrible
Posted 5 months ago by Lauren L.
Unfortunately made chicken burger - extremely oily and unhealthy on a bad tasting bread. Chips were awful. Smoothies of poor quality. Delivery late.
Posted 10 months ago by Eric B.
I'm surprised to see some negative reviews here. They typically hit their 30-45 min delivery time and the salads are some of the best I've ordered off Seamless. Fresh, good quality stuff, and large sized portions. They do occasionally call about needing to replace a soup I've ordred, but they're always nice and pretty efficient about it. Will continue ordering from here regularly.
Posted 10 months ago by Elisabeth S.
90 minutes after my food hadn't arrive: "The girl who got your order didn't do it and she left"
Posted a year ago by PHILIP E F.
Normally I don't bother to rate if I had a bad experience, but this was over the top. Had to wait almost 2 hours for my dinner. Called them 3 times to only hear them selling me BS. When it arrived, it was cold and tasted bad. How can you mess up pasta? This is the last time I order from this place, it is always something with them.
Posted a year ago by Carolina F.
Second time I've received frozen edamame which is just irritating at this point. The quality of the food seems to have dropped off overall as of late, but it could just be what I'm ordering.
Posted a year ago by Melissa L.
The soups are awful. The Amish Market has taken an extreme turn for the worse. they obviously no longer care who cooks their food. how sad, another establishment that chose profit over quality.
Posted a year ago by Chen H.
Absolutely terrible service. Delivery driver called me 15 minutes before he arrived, I waited for 10 then went back upstairs. When I called to complain to the restaurant they told me the driver was very busy. I reminded him that I am the one eating dinner at my desk and his delivery man should keep that in mind. He then replied "I don't like you already" and then hung up. Avoid it. They are terrible.
Posted a year ago by Mark L.
very good food. but sooooo slow
Posted a year ago by Mia Q.
I waited an hour and then called the restaurant to find out where the food was and they told me they didn't send the order b/c they didn't have one of the items. I asked why they didn't call to replace the item and they said, "don't know."
Posted a year ago by Alan S.
Very slow delivery - late.
Posted a year ago by Alex H.
Food is good, if they have it. Called half an hour after placing my order and said that they did not have 5 of the 6 items I had ordered. I told them to cancel the order. I was still charged for the order. I am still waiting on Seamless to refund an order I never received.
Posted a year ago by Ken M.
I have ordered from here a handful of times and EVERY single time the food takes 1.5 hrs to arrive to the point where you need to call to track down your order. I'm done with this place.
Posted a year ago by John K.
Vegetables are the freshest available
Posted 2 years ago by Shannon B.
Ordered the pizza - it was fresh, hot and delicious. Delivery was fast (40 min).
Posted 2 years ago by Avinash R.
quick delivery and amazing tomato chedder soup
Posted 2 years ago by James Z.
Probably the third time they've messed up my order, and i've only ordered from them about 6 times! I'm not liking my odds...
Posted 2 years ago by Ivan R.
The burger was terrible. The fries arrived wet from all the moisture of the bad packaging. The burger was supposed to be cooked medium rare yet showed up well done. gross.
Posted 2 years ago by michael m.
I've ordered sandwiches, pizzas, and salads from here. All have been outstanding! I'm gonna try the pastas next!
Posted 2 years ago by Carmine L.
Slow delivery... inefficient staff. I ordered for myself and 2 coworkers... after nearly an hour they showed up... with only 2 of the 3 items we ordered. Of the two items which showed up, one was wrong (we ordered a BBQ Chicken Sandwich and got a Turkey sandwich instead). NEVER ordering from here again. Save yourself the trouble and order somewhere else!!
Posted 2 years ago by Deven M.
Do not believe the 30-45 min order.. I live all but 5 min walk away and they still managed to be late.. Took 63 minutes and got me the wrong drink...
Posted 2 years ago by Vincent S.
I want to give them a better rating but the pizza delivery skills leave a lot to be desired. The last 3 times we've ordered from them the pizza has arrived soggy, mangled or both.
Posted 2 years ago by Gary M.
The tomato cheddar soup is soooo good, but last time they delivered ... it spilled everywhere and half of it was gone!!! ERRR
Posted 3 years ago by Irmingard M.
Delicious corn chowder. Nearly as good as the one I used to make. Wow. Speedy delivery, too!
Posted 3 years ago by Akilah R.
always slow, one time took 2.5 hours...
Posted 3 years ago by Harish P.
When SW said the delivery would take 15-30 minutes, an HOUR AND FIFTEEN MINUTES LATER, we still did not have our food. After multiple calls inquiring as to the status of our food, we finally got it... and the order was incorrect. TWO MORE calls trying to fix the order, and we did not receive the fixed order. Food quality also completely sub-par. Don't waste your time or money with this place.
Posted 3 years ago by Daina S.
Terrible service
Posted 3 years ago by Gopal T.
I order from this place about once a week. They deliver on time and the food is good. Their Cobb Salad and their soups are excellent. The sandwiches are also pretty good.
Posted 3 years ago by Eric W.
very late, no utensils, bad taste
Posted 3 years ago by David L.
Nice selection of products (pizzas especially good) Great taste Long delivery time. Have waited over an hour many times.
Posted 4 years ago by Douglas E. T.
Very poor service
Posted 4 years ago by Ena L.
When after 40 minutes or more the delivery guy arrived, he took another 20 minutes to reach my door because he didn't read the delivery instructions specifying which apartment I was in. Then, instead of the paninin with turkey and gruyere that I ordered, I got turkey on panini bread with no cheese and cold (paninins are supposed to be hot pressed). When I called to complain, instead of offering to comp me what was sent, they wanted it back before refunding the money. It wasn't what I ordered and what I was looking forward to eating, but at least it was something to eat and I would have expected a comp for my troubles. Nope. I should have listed to the other reviewers when they warned of the horrible delivery service...
Posted 4 years ago by Kerry K.
Food itself was good, it took over an hour for delivery which was unacceptable, pizza was lukewarm so I had to put it in the convection oven.
Posted 4 years ago by Trevor T.
the spaghetti bolognese is one of my favorite and comes in huge portions. but the food takes so long to arrive that i may stop ordering from here. the seamlessweb receipt says the food will only take 20 to 35 minutes to arrive, but 9 times out of 10 (and I have ordered from them many many times) the food has taken over an hour, at least, to arrive. if you do not have the patience to wait up to an hour and a half for a pizza or for spaghetti, then do not order from this place.
Posted 4 years ago by Jessica L.
The order took more than 90 minutes to be delivered and it was not any special day or any bad weather situation... not to mention one of the pizza was really cold... too bad we actually liked this place.
Posted 4 years ago by Zouhair S.
Great food, good service
Posted 4 years ago by Donna F.
Sometimes slow on delivery but great food!
Posted 4 years ago by Alyssa Yao G.
Love this place, but you've got about a 50/50 chance of getting what you order. I've ordered four times... once received the wrong type of bread on each of two sandwiches and the yogurt & granola was missing the granola, another time i received the wrong bread and wrong condiment. However, when they get the order right, it is delicious and very reasonably priced.
Posted 5 years ago by Abigail S.
Exceptional food; Immediate delivery; outstanding service
Posted 6 years ago by Isabell A.
Only select user reviews are published on Seamless. All user-submitted ratings contribute to Amish Market West's overall Seamless rating, but we manually screen all reviews and only publish those that are relevant and helpful. Tips for getting your review published »
Above content provided by restaurant.
Order online from Amish Market West by entering your address below. Online ordering powered by Seamless.com.
Return users log in here.
Click a menu item to add it to your order.
Back to top